This piston set never left the box they arrived to me in, so the damage i am seeing in this thread is new to me...i'd like to make that clear.
I removed one piston from this box on the day of my engine rebuild to fit my new OEM nissan rings and basically found the rings didn't fit, hence why i didn't use them. The one piston that was removed had a tiny minor scuff (I'm guessing pic 4) that IMO didn't warrant a mention on a used part.
Phil mentioned this damage via pm, and i said i had seen a small scuff that i said didn't warrant a mention in my opinion and basically shrugged it off. Although i am now left a little annoyed, the other pistons have slightly worse damage which i admit i hadn't even looked at.
I didn't even know that the pistons and rods i sold came with ARP rod bolts, which Phil brought to my attention, so i have to admit i've been a bit ignorant to these parts since i purchased them. I bought them and sold them.
It is odd that the marks are in the same areas on the pistons, but I also don't think these are engine related damages, particularly from looking at piston pic 3 as a bit of metal appears to be left sticking out.
I'd be happy to take these pistons back Phil and give you a refund, but i don't think thats what you want to do.